$25 to $50

Cuddle up with the ultra soft and squishy, sweet Folkmanis® Manatee. This gentle marine mammal is curious, peaceful, and takes life at a slow pace....

Marshmallow Zoo is made of the softest plush Mary Meyers Stuffed Toys could sink Mary Meyers Stuffed Toys' fingers in, and continues to lead in the...

Marshmallow Zoo characters are ready for anything, even if it’s just snuggling in bed for a little comfort and courage. Part pet, part doll, and al...

Marshmallow Zoo is made of the softest plush we could sink our fingers in, and continues to lead in the "what fabulous fabric!" category. Marshmall...

Marshmallow Zoo characters are ready for anything, even if it's just snuggling in bed for a little comfort and courage. Part pet, part doll, and al...

Marshmallow Zoo is made of the softest plush we could sink our fingers in, and continues to lead in the “what fabulous fabric!” category. Marshmall...

Matcha! It's ground-up green tea powder! It's also a popular Japanese drink made OF that ground up green tea powder! It's also an Instagrammable pi...

Maurice Macaroni is a blue-grey penguin, gorgeously squat with a round cream bib and custard-yellow tufts. With waggly flippers, stitch suedette fe...

Meet your new bedtime buddy! This adorable White Lab plush arrives dressed in festive holiday pajamas, ready for cozy cuddles and imaginative adven...

Melvin the Dragon would love to be your friend, if you’ll have him! This melancholy purple and orange dragon has a gentle spirit. Melvin is a quiet...

Merry Mouse is holiday-happy in a splendid Santa outfit. Huggably soft in scarlet velour, this jacket and hat have a fuzzy cream trim. They set off...

Merry Mouse Present is a gift with a gift. This dreamy cream mouse has foldy waggle ears, a suedey peach tail and neat suedey paws. Wearing a sprig...

Messenger Bunny has a very important message to deliver! Super soft in mushroom colored fur with a cream fluffy bobtail, this bunny has a suedette ...

When twilight comes, look out for Miff Mothman! This mythical friend has a silky black tummy, embroidered slate wings with scalloped edges and a fu...

You found him! After decades, nay, centuries of ambling about the forests of the Pacific Northwest, it took a noble soul such as yourself to coax M...

This super squishy avocado is so cute we can't decide if we want to eat it up or just squeeze it really hard! All 12" of Birthday Avocado is bursti...

This super squishy Bubble Tea is so cute we can't decide if we want to drink it up or just squeeze it really hard! All 11" of this purple boba tea ...

Introducing the Mini Bunny Cactus Squishable, a surprising and deliciously adorable addition to your collection! This prickly pal may not be edible...

Bake their day with this suuuuper squishy whimsical plush. Is it a cat? A loaf of bread? There's no way to know for sure! Fluffy brown fur wraps ar...

Everyone knows that the best things come in threes. Musketeers! Billy Goats Gruff! Wise men! Little Pigs! The list goes on! Why, I can't even imagi...

You know what this summer is missing? A soft squishy buggy buddy whose butt glows in the dark. Get your summer glow on with an adorable 10" firefly...

Hop into cuteness overload with the Mini Grasshopper Squishable! This quirky plush adds a touch of humor to any room. Plus, it's a gentle reminder ...

Do you slurp on Ghost Pepper shakes? Do you chomp on Carolina Reapers like potato chips? Do you keep hot sauce in your bag for flavor crises? Do yo...

Hey Mini Lich! You crazy undead necromancer you, how the heck are ya doing? I haven't seen you in centuries! You look great! No really, for an anci...