Mythical & Unique

Ghastly the plush Ghost has been dutifully attending his classes at boo school but is unlikely to be scaring anyone this spooky season! Ghastly’s r...

West Virginians!!! Also everyone else! REJOICE as the Baby Mothman has now graced us with their largest presence yet!! Imagine coming home from a l...

This Baby Mothman Snugglemi Snacker is sure to charm and terrify your pals! It's a perfect sidekick for your everyday adventures, whether you're lo...

Skeleton avocado? Oh - that's just its alter ego! Give it a hug and feel how squishy it is, with its special soft fur and slightly weighted base. 5...

Three heads are definitely better than one, and only slightly cooler than two! Think of it like always having someone to talk to about your day! Th...

Bring home Blink, the silly two-eyed monster from Mary Meyer’s Fabfuzz collection! Standing 12 inches tall, this plush pal features a super soft, u...

Meet Tink Monster Plush, the mischievous three-eyed buddy ready to spark joy in your day. Standing 12" tall, Tink features a bold, fresh color pale...

It's cuddly, really! Here's your chance to hug a venus fly trap without any of the bugs. Give it a squeeze and feel the softness! 24 squishy inches...

Start your morning off right with Devil's Brew Alter Ego Coffee! This mischievous Squishable is both cute and sassy, The perfect sidekick for any c...

Deep within the earth, in the dark chasms where no one returns, beyond all sense and light, comes the voice of the mighty ancient terror. And behol...

Everyone knows that the best things come in threes. Musketeers! Billy Goats Gruff! Wise men! Little Pigs! The list goes on! Why, I can't even imagi...

Meet Mary Meyer's Fun Frights Monster Plush Assortment—three lovable, not-so-scary monsters made from irresistibly soft fabric, perfect for little ...

Get ready to meet Wink, the quirky one-eyed wonder from Mary Meyer’s Fabfuzz Monster collection! Standing 12" tall, this snuggly friend boasts a bo...

Meet Weaver, the enchanting round grey spider Beanie Boo! With her glittery green button eyes and adorable tiny smile, she’s ready to add a sprinkl...

⚠️ Unfortunately, we are unable to ship this product. It is currently available for in-store pickup and local delivery only. ⚠️ Medieval plague...

Space-alien avocado? Oh - that's just its alter ego! Give it a hug and feel how squishy it is, with its special soft fur and slightly weighted base...

Listen to this Spooky Druid's advice. But be warned, for this advice is cursed! Once you hear it, you'll never be able to unhear it! Even when you ...

All fun and whimsy, when it comes to Flappie the Mini Soft Bat stuffed animal, there’s nothing to fear from our playful take on this famous creatur...

Beware, for I see a vital decision in your near future! One path contains sorrow, one joy! Mere seconds from now, you will finish reading the descr...

Hopefully we all went through a Greek Mythology phase in middle/high school. Like, we all pretendeded that Greek Gods were the ultimate personality...

All hail Mini King Raven! Our majesty rules the dark skies with might and grace! Truly we are honored to witness the flex of their feathers, the fl...

Hey Mini Lich! You crazy undead necromancer you, how the heck are ya doing? I haven't seen you in centuries! You look great! No really, for an anci...

I feel like someone is watching me! Is it the shadow of paranoia hiding in my subconscious? No, it's a Shadow Dragon...hiding in my shadow! Come on...

Clumsy, quirky and very cuddly!Thump! Bang! Clatter! You always know when Pip Monster's about! This bold, beany monster has masses of tousled ginge...